Skip to content Accessibility info

Rathbun Insurance Blog

All You Ever Wanted to Know About Insurance

When to Think Twice About Filing Low-Value Insurance Claims

Insurance is a valuable safety net that helps protect us from unexpected financial burdens in times of crisis. Whether it's for your home, car, or health, insurance provides peace of mind. However, it's essential to understand that not all claims are created equal. In this blog, we'll delve into why it might not always be in your best interest to turn in low-value insurance claims, with a particular focus on home insurance and property-related claims.

Before we get into the details, let's touch on the concept of insurance ratings. Insurers assign risk ratings to policyholders based on various factors. One crucial element is your claims history. Every claim you file goes on your record and can impact your insurance premium. The more claims you file, especially for minor or low-value incidents, the higher the risk rating you may receive.

So, why does this matter? Insurance premiums are calculated based on risk. If you're deemed a high-risk policyholder, your premiums are likely to increase. This could potentially offset any benefits gained from filing a low-value claim. Let's explore this further.

When it comes to home insurance, one common scenario where this concept applies is roof damage. Many homeowners insurance policies cover roof damage caused by certain perils, like storms or falling trees. However, some policies may include a clause that requires an inspection to assess the condition of your roof before providing coverage for repairs or replacement.

If you've recently experienced minor damage to your roof, such as a few missing shingles or small leaks, it's tempting to file a claim for the repairs. However, before doing so, consider the following:

  1. Deductibles: Most insurance policies have a deductible, which is the amount you must pay out of pocket before your insurer covers the rest. For minor repairs, your deductible might be equal to or higher than the repair cost, making the claim essentially worthless.
  2. Premium Impact: As mentioned earlier, filing a claim can affect your insurance premiums. Even if your claim is approved and you receive a payout, your premiums might increase for several years, potentially outweighing the financial benefit of the claim.
  3. Inspection Requirement: If your policy requires a roof inspection, it's essential to fulfill this requirement. If you file a claim without getting an inspection, your claim may be denied, leaving you with no payout and the potential for higher premiums.
  4. Loss History: Frequent claims, even for minor issues, can lead to a history of losses that may make it difficult to find affordable insurance in the future.

While insurance is meant to provide protection and financial support during challenging times, it's crucial to exercise discretion when considering filing a claim, especially for low-value incidents. Before rushing to report minor damage or losses, assess the situation and weigh the potential benefits against the long-term consequences.

Remember that insurance should primarily serve as a safety net for significant and unforeseen events that could otherwise lead to financial ruin. By being mindful of your claims history and considering the impact on your premiums, you can make informed decisions that truly serve your best interests in the long run. If you're uncertain about whether to file a claim, it's always a good idea to consult with your Rathbun Insruanc account manager for policy and coverage information regarding your specific situation.